Facebook App Center Request "Play Now" Broken

Facebook App Center Request "Play Now" Broken

--QUESTION--
In the FB App Center, my requests show up with the "Play Now" button. When
I click "Play Now", it tries to take me to
facebook.com/apps/application.php?id=xxxxxxxxxxxxxx. Clicking on this
takes me to a page that says "Sorry, this page isn't available". How do I
get this to take me to the App Details page like all the other apps I've
seen?
--BACKGROUND--
Our game is currently iOS only but we are adding full FB web support in a
few months
Our FB app is in sandbox mode
The FB user I'm using to SEND the request is a developer on the FB app
The FB user I'm using to RECEIVE the request is a tester on the FB app
I have setup the basic information that seems to be required in
developers.facebook.com/apps/xxxxxxxxxxxxx/appdetails
Since the game is currently iOS only, the only thing setup in the basic
app settings is the "Native iOS App" portion
--OTHER INFO--
I've been using Hay Day as an example because it is also iOS only. When I
send myself a request from Hay Day, it shows up in the App
Center->Requests section but it is slightly different. I can't attach
images, so here is a link for a side-by-side comparison of the Hay Day
request vs. our Tunnel Town request:
https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/60541766/FB_Requests.PNG
Here is an example of the Hay Day appcenter page:
https://www.facebook.com/appcenter/haydaygame?fb_source=appcenter_request
Thanks so much for the help!